"Oh, that New Zealand guy? Yea, that sounds crazy. I was in North Carolina and it was all over the radio," Bailey replies. "In my eyes, she didn't do nothing wrong," he says, referring to the mother who shot Skinner.
"They would've been dead - if she didn't have a gun. They would've all been dead," Dale Agnew says.
Sitting at the next table, Hashaam Markas, 33, introduces himself to Sheriff Agnew and says he's only recently moved into the county.
"There was a New Zealander committing crimes in Goochland, Virginia? Now that is odd," Markas says, overhearing the conversation. "Did the homeowner shoot him? Did she shoot him dead?" he asks.
No, the sheriff replies. In the neck, but he's alive. "If there's ever a reason to have a gun, it was proven last Friday," he says. Both men nod.
Chris and Courtney Subudhi, who live on Steeplechase Parkway with their five kids aged 3 to 11, were home on the afternoon of the attack, but say they didn't hear anything. When they found out what had happened, they say, the most striking element of the incident to them was that the man came from New Zealand.
"That's a really far trip. No one just shows up in Goochland, we're just a blip on a map," Courtney says. "Plus, New Zealand is so beautiful, why would he want to leave and come all the way over here for some girl?"
Brian Sylvester, who lives five houses down from the incident, says he was also at home at the time of the shooting but heard nothing. He was in the front yard, beside the pool, with his son and his son's girlfriend, shooting his own .22-calibre handgun at targets.
Sylvester's father is a certified NRA instructor; Sylvester says this case was a perfect example of the need for home protection in America. "He was not there just to say hello to her daughter. I firmly believe the family would've been hurt if she didn't have a gun."
His wife, Jennifer, criticises American media for only highlighting stories that support the gun control mantra and says cases like this always fly under the national radar. "I work with people in Richmond who haven't even heard of this story. This is a great example of the use of a gun. She did the right thing, but home protection stories are never followed up in America."
Jennifer Sylvester says that before the attack she wasn't sure she would be able to shoot an intruder, but now she wants to sign up for target practice, just in case. "We hope the family is going to be okay," she says. "It's a pretty big deal when you pull the trigger. That's quite a load to carry."
The family involved in the attack have asked for privacy and neighbours tell the Weekend Herald they have agreed to protect their identity from reporters.
Skinner will likely be discharged from hospital this week.
He will then be moved to the Henrico County Jail, where he will appear in court via video link for a bond hearing that will almost certainly be denied. Skinner has rights to a lawyer, but so far none has been appointed.
Patients in the incarceration ward of the VCU Medical Centre Critical Care Hospital are not allowed visitors or phone calls, the Weekend Herald is told. Sheriff Agnew received a call from Skinner's father in New Zealand last week, asking how his son was doing. Agnew told him Skinner was still in hospital and refusing to speak to officers.
On Skinner's release from hospital, he will enter the American justice system, where he will face trial for a class two felony, which carries a potential sentence of life imprisonment.
Troy Skinner's movements ahead of arrest.
June 20
• 6:05am, June 20: Qantas flight QF140 - Auckland to Sydney.
• 9:25am – Qantas flight AA72 - Sydney to Los Angeles.
• 9:40pm – American Airlines flight: AA303 – Los Angeles to Washington D.C.
June 21
• 8:35am, June 21, Greyhound bus: Washington D.C. to Richmond, Va.
• 3:03pm – checked into Hosteling International USA in Richmond, Va
June 22
• 8:46am, June 22, checked out of Hosteling International USA
• 12:45pm, bought knife and duct tape at Wal-Mart in Glen Allen, Va.
• 2.30pm, resident of Holland Hills subdivision, while driving out of neighborhood, notices male walking in black clothing with a backpack crossing the road along Bulldog Way and Steeplechase Parkway.
• About 4:27pm, Goochland emergency services receive call from resident about Skinner breaking into their family home.